Member-only story

Is Opposition to Immigration a Subtle Form of Racism?

Immigration has always been a contentious topic. However, beneath these arguments lies a deeper question: could resistance to immigration sometimes act as a subtle signal for racial bias?

Libby Winkler
4 min readJan 2, 2025
Photo by Joseph Lockley on Unsplash

Is Opposition to Immigration a Subtle Form of Racism?

Immigration has always been contentious, often framed around economic priorities, national security, or cultural identity. However, beneath these arguments lies a deeper question: could resistance to immigration sometimes act as a subtle signal for racial bias?

Decoding the Dog Whistle

A “dog whistle” refers to language crafted to seem harmless or neutral but conveys specific, often controversial, messages to a particular audience. In immigration debates, specific phrases — like “defend Western values” or “protect our borders” — may sound reasonable on the surface but often tap into nativist or xenophobic attitudes without directly mentioning race.

A History of Exclusion

The history of U.S. immigration policy reveals long-standing racial underpinnings. Laws like the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and…

--

--

Libby Winkler
Libby Winkler

Written by Libby Winkler

Freelance writer who loves exploring the messiness of humanity, while poking around in nooks of life and shining light on all the things that make us complex..

Responses (1)